Why Is It So Hard to Change Even When I Want To?
Most people assume that if we really wanted to change, we would.
If we truly wanted to leave the relationship, we'd leave.
If we wanted to drink less, we'd stop.
If we wanted to set a boundary, we'd say no.
If we wanted to start therapy, we'd book the appointment.
So when we find ourselves making the same promise over and over…
"This is the last time."
"Tomorrow will be different."
"Next week I'll finally..."
…it can be easy to reach one conclusion:
"There must be something wrong with me."
But what if the problem isn't that you don't want to change?
What if the problem is that different parts of you want different things?
Change is rarely one decision.
We often imagine change as a straight line.
You decide and then you act. Your life gets better.
Real life is rarely that simple!
Most meaningful changes involve letting go of something that has helped us - even if it's also hurting us.
Maybe alcohol has become the only time your mind feels quiet.
Maybe staying in the relationship feels safer than facing the unknown.
Maybe saying yes to everyone keeps conflict at a distance.
Maybe overworking protects you from feeling like you're falling behind.
If a behaviour has been helping you survive, it makes sense that another part of you would be reluctant to let it go.
That doesn't mean you don't want to change.
It means change is asking you to give something up before you've found another way to meet that need.
The part of you that doesn't want to change isn't your enemy.
One of the biggest shifts that happens in therapy is moving away from asking,
"How do I get rid of this part of me?"
and toward asking,
"What is this part trying to protect?"
That question changes everything.
The part that keeps drinking may be trying to create relief after an overwhelming day.
The part that stays in unhealthy relationships may be trying to protect you from loneliness.
The part that avoids difficult conversations may be trying to keep you safe from rejection.
The part that keeps saying "yes" may be trying to preserve connection.
None of these strategies are random, they developed for a reason.
Understanding that reason doesn't mean you have to keep them but it's often the first step toward changing them.
Knowing isn't the same as being ready.
One of the most frustrating parts of change is that insight doesn't always create action.
You can know a relationship isn't healthy and still struggle to leave.
You can know alcohol isn't helping anymore and still pour another drink.
You can know you deserve better and still find yourself repeating the same pattern.
That isn't a failure!
Research on behaviour change has consistently shown that ambivalence - wanting change while also wanting things to stay the same - is a totally normal part of the process.
In other words, you don't have to wait until you're 100% sure before change becomes possible.
Why being hard on yourself usually backfires.
Many of us believe that if we were just tougher on ourselves, we'd finally change.
So we criticize ourselves for not trying harder, we compare ourselves to people who seem to have figured it out, and we tell ourselves we should know better by now.
The problem is that shame often keeps us stuck.
When we're overwhelmed by self-criticism, our attention shifts from learning to surviving.
Instead of asking,
"What happened?"
we ask,
"What's wrong with me?"
Research suggests that people who respond to setbacks with greater self-compassion are often more willing to try again, learn from mistakes, and continue making changes over time.
Compassion isn't the opposite of accountability, it's what makes accountability sustainable.
Change usually starts long before anyone notices.
We often think change begins the day someone quits drinking, leaves a relationship, or sets a boundary.
But meaningful change usually starts much earlier.
It starts with curiosity.
The moment you pause before acting automatically, or you ask yourself,
"Is this still working for me?"
These varied moments may seem small, but they’re not. They're often the beginning of everything that comes next.
We can’t try to leap to the top of the staircase - we have to take it one step at a time.
A different question.
If you've been asking yourself,
"Why can't I change?"
I'd like to offer you a different question instead.
"What makes this change so difficult?"
Because one question assumes there's something wrong with you while the other assumes your behaviour makes sense.
And if your behaviour makes sense, then it can also be understood.
From there, change stops being a battle against yourself.
It becomes a process of understanding yourself well enough to build something different.
Continue Reading
If this article resonated with you, you might also enjoy:
What the Research Tells Us
The ideas in this article are informed by decades of research on motivation, behaviour change, and self-compassion.
Ambivalence is a normal part of change. Feeling pulled in two directions doesn't mean you're unmotivated. It often means you're weighing something important. Motivational Interviewing views ambivalence as something to explore, not eliminate.
Lasting change is more likely when it comes from your own values. Research consistently shows that people are more likely to sustain change when it feels personally meaningful rather than driven by pressure or shame.
Behaviours usually serve a purpose. Whether it's alcohol, avoidance, overworking, or people-pleasing, behaviours often continue because they reduce distress or meet an emotional need. Understanding that function is an important part of creating lasting change.
Self-compassion supports growth. Studies have found that responding to setbacks with kindness rather than harsh self-criticism is associated with greater resilience, emotional well-being, and persistence when making difficult changes.
